The short answerRepair the furnace if it's under 15 years old and the repair costs less than about a third of a new system. Replace it if multiplying its age by the repair cost gives more than $5,000, if it has a cracked heat exchanger, or if it has needed several repairs in the last two years.
1. Start with the $5,000 rule
Multiply your furnace's age by the repair quote. If the answer is under $5,000, repairing usually makes sense. If it's over, replacement is usually the better value.
- A 9-year-old furnace with a $300 igniter repair: 9 × $300 = $2,700. Repair it.
- A 17-year-old furnace with a $650 inducer motor: 17 × $650 = $11,050. Start looking at replacement.
It's a rule of thumb, not a law. It ignores comfort and efficiency, which is why the rest of this checklist matters.
2. How old is it, really?
Gas furnaces typically last 15 to 20 years. You'll find the manufacture date on the data plate inside the furnace door, or we can decode it from the serial number. Past 15 years, parts get harder to find and the next repair is rarely the last.
3. What common repairs cost
| Repair | Typical price | Worth it on an old furnace? |
|---|---|---|
| Flame sensor clean or replace | $150 – $220 | Yes |
| Hot surface igniter | $220 – $320 | Yes |
| Blower capacitor | $180 – $260 | Yes |
| Inducer motor | $550 – $850 | Depends on age |
| Control board | $450 – $750 | Depends on age |
| Heat exchanger | $1,500 – $3,000 | Rarely |
4. Safety issues decide it for you
A cracked heat exchanger can let carbon monoxide into your home. When we find one, we show you photos and shut the furnace off. On a furnace past 12 years old, replacing it almost always beats replacing the heat exchanger.
Every home with a gas furnace should have a working carbon monoxide alarm on each floor. They cost less than a pizza.
5. Count the hidden costs
An older 80% furnace turns 80 cents of every gas dollar into heat. A 96% furnace turns 96 cents into heat, so it uses about 17% less gas for the same warmth. In a typical Columbus winter, that difference is real money every month.
6. When I tell people to keep the old one
If the furnace is under 15 years old, has been maintained and needs an inexpensive part, keep it. A good technician should be just as happy to fix your furnace as to sell you a new one. At Kestrel, we're paid the same either way.
Quick questions
Is it worth repairing a 20-year-old furnace?
Only for a small, inexpensive repair to get you through the season. At 20 years, plan the replacement so you can choose the system instead of being forced into it on a cold night.
How long does a furnace replacement take?
Most like-for-like furnace replacements are finished in one day, including removal of the old unit, permits and testing.


